A developer and homeowners in Flushing are locked in a legal dispute over a century-old deed restriction that prohibits apartment buildings in most of the neighborhood. The conflict revolves around a proposed 10-story mixed-use structure at 158-06 Northern Boulevard, which would include 76 apartments, 19 of them designated as affordable units. The city approved the project in October, but the Broadway-Flushing Homeowners’ Association and residents including Raymond and Barbara Ciccolilli have filed a lawsuit to halt construction, claiming it violates the Rickert-Finlay Covenants, a set of 28 deed restrictions established in 1906.
The covenants were created to maintain the area’s original park-like design, explicitly barring apartment buildings outside a specific subdivision zone. The proposed site lies outside that designated area. The homeowners association, formed in 1964 to enforce these rules, argues the development contradicts the neighborhood’s intended residential character. Apex Development, the project’s sponsor, disputes this, asserting the restrictions are outdated and discriminatory. They claim the covenants unfairly exclude minority and lower-income renters, potentially violating the Fair Housing Act.
The developer highlights that the property has served commercial functions for decades, operating as a restaurant and dialysis center. Apex argues that enforcing these restrictions would perpetuate segregation by blocking multifamily housing in a neighborhood that has long since departed from its original suburban layout. The legal proceedings have paused the project while both sides prepare for court battles at federal and state levels.
Andrew Esposito, president of Apex Development, stressed the importance of resolving the issue. “The property has been used for commercial purposes for decades, including as a restaurant and dialysis center, according to the developer’s complaint. Apex argues that enforcing the covenants would vio,” he said. Esposito also noted, “We take community relations very seriously and we remain willing to find an amicable solution, but we believe housing is a critical necessity right now, and we’re not going to be discouraged by 120-year-old restrictive covenants.” The homeowners’ association declined to comment.
