Mamdani disputes math behind NYC rent-stabilized vacancy figures

by Samantha White • 17 hours ago
Mamdani disputes math behind NYC rent-stabilized vacancy figures

Share It:

Debate over rent-stabilized vacancies in New York City centers on a disagreement over math and methodology. One widely cited figure puts the number of rent-stabilized units in the city registered as vacant at 57,000 in 2025, according to Division of Housing and Community Renewal data released in June. An update this week showed a higher number of empty rent-stabilized units in 2025, just above 60,000, adding April 2026 data that reflects more than 58,000 vacancies.

Mayor says the numbers show a different story

Mayor Zohran Mamdani contested these figures during the New York Times’ Dealbook Summit on Wednesday, reigniting discussions about the true number of dormant rent-stabilized units. His stance comes as Albany lawmakers face pressure to amend the 2019 Housing Stability and Tenant Protection Act. The City Council is also seeking clarity, with Council member Farah Louis proposing legislation this month to mandate the Department of Housing Preservation and Development to investigate vacancy causes and suggest policies to reintegrate units into the rental market.

“So I have looked at the numbers. And what the numbers show is that only about 6,000 have been vacant for five years,” Mamdani said at the Dealbook event. “The reason that that’s important is a lot of the units that are being described in that data set are also units of newly constructed rent-stabilized housing, because rent-stabilized housing is not only pre-1974 housing. It’s also housing that’s being developed, you know, what was once 421a, 485x, all these different subsidy programs.”

In essence, the mayor is claiming that fewer units are offline due to disrepair after years of occupancy, leaving them in dilapidated conditions, than newly built vacant rent-stabilized units waiting to be leased out.

Industry officials question the mayor’s claims

The mayor didn’t even deny that 6,000 apartments have been unavailable to live in for five years, according to Kenny Burgos, CEO of the New York Apartment Association. “We know it’s higher. DHCR says at least 57,000, plus more than 30,000 registered as temporarily exempt.”

Read Also: Flushing homeowners, developer clash over housing restrictions

REBNY President Jim Whelan urged, ‘Let the facts settle the debate.’ He called for focusing on affordable housing solutions, such as renovating older apartments and improving the housing lottery, emphasizing transparency and results over disputes.

Without mayoral support, the industry will need to make a strong case if it expects lawmakers to change the status quo on rent-stabilized vacancies. Many landlords have argued that the HSTPA disincentivizes or prevents them from making costly repairs to lease the units.

A 2024 study by former comptroller Brad Lander, recently elected to represent parts of Lower Manhattan and Brooklyn in Congress, estimated that fewer than 2,000 rent-stabilized units in the city were sitting vacant due to landlords’ inability to make repairs and notes that the proportion that sat empty for that specific reason fell between 2021 and 2023.

“To create a scenario where it’s rational for landlords to warehouse apartments and padlock them … is one of the single dumbest things I’ve ever experienced in my life,” REBNY chair and Two Trees Development CEO Jed Walentas said at the 2024 NY Forum. “You could link [the units] up with vouchers. There are a million ways to solve the problem.”

“Did a landlord write that question?” the mayor asked, adding that he was teasing moderator Andrew Ross Sorkin before highlighting supply-side fixes and better preservation as priorities.

Leave A Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *